Lawyers and MPs put their weight behind family

 Mohammed Kalim and his wife Firoza Begum. PHOTO: GREGOR RICHARDSON
Mohammed Kalim and his wife Firoza Begum. PHOTO: GREGOR RICHARDSON
The Balclutha family of a Fijian woman facing deportation now face a nervous wait, following positive developments in her case yesterday.

Wheelchair-bound stroke victim Firoza Begum (57) was set to comply with an Immigration New Zealand deportation order by flying to Fiji with husband Mohammed Kalim (63) on Saturday.

Hamish Walker
Hamish Walker

The disabled grandmother became an unintentional overstayer in January after a clerical error at Immigration NZ delayed her annual visa application.

When her predicament was reported by the Otago Daily Times on Monday, messages of support began to flood in, including several offers of advice and help.

Yesterday, Wilkinson Rodgers Lawyers managing partner Geoff Mirkin contacted the ODT offering the firm's pro bono services to Mrs Begum and her family.

In addition, Clutha-Southland MP Hamish Walker and Central Otago New Zealand First list MP Mark Patterson threw their support behind Mrs Begum by registering separate appeals for ministerial intervention.

Mark Patterson
Mark Patterson

Mr Mirkin said he could not comment on the case in detail without knowing all the facts, but he and his team had assisted clients in similar situations successfully in the past.

The complexities of immigration law meant there often remained unexplored avenues to consider, he said.

Mr Walker said he had requested an urgent intervention from Associate Immigration Minister Poto Williams to allow Mrs Begum to stay.

''Mohammed and Firoza are valued members of our community and have contributed hugely through their employment at Silver Fern Farms and New World. They've been put in a very stressful situation.''

Poto Williams
Poto Williams

Mr Patterson said he and other supporters were launching a ''rearguard action'' on the family's behalf.

''Unfortunately, time is against us, but I've written to Mrs Williams' office, and hope a compassionate outcome can be reached in this case.''

Mr Kalim welcomed the offers of assistance, but remained cautious.

He said his wife and family were doing the ''best they could'' under the strain of events and did not want to ''make things worse''.

''We appreciate the offers of help, but with only days to go, we don't want to give ourselves false hope and undo plans, only to have to buy new airplane tickets and motel rooms in a few days' time. We're all tired and very stressed.''

Daughter Farina Shah, who moved to Balclutha in 2012 to be closer to her parents, said she would still like her mother to remain in New Zealand.

''We've received a lot of support from friends and colleagues since the story came out. Unfortunately Immigration [NZ] are still digging their heels in, even though they've acknowledged they made a mistake. We're trying to stay positive, but it's very hard.''

Questioned about apparent inconsistencies in its assessment of Mrs Begum's medical status since she had her stroke in 2016, Immigration NZ said it had followed guidelines.

''Mrs Begum's medical issues were first identified as part of her work visa application in 2017. When the decision to approve the application was made, it was noted she would need to submit updated test results if she reapplied for a visa.

''When she did so in 2018 ... new information led INZ to determine Mrs Begum did not have an acceptable standard of health ... and did not qualify for an exception. INZ, therefore, declined the application in 2018.''

A spokeswoman for Mrs Williams' office said no further comment would be made until she had addressed the request for intervention.


Are we promoting lawlessness? The temporary Visa was based on clear conditions which have been breached. End of story, follow the rules. We can not provide health care to the world- one would expect them to be thankful for the time they had to be in NZ instead of demanding things we NZers do not even get. Remember, many tens of thousands of kiwis are on waiting lists for surgeries and treatment- they need to come first.






Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter