Peters says no to 'dangerous settlement' of Ihumātao

New Zealand First leader Winston Peters campaigning at Ōrewa Community Centre in Auckland on 25...
New Zealand First leader Winston Peters campaigning at Ōrewa Community Centre in Auckland on 25 September. Photo: RNZ
New Zealand First leader Winston Peters has used a speech at Orewa to call protesters objecting to a housing development at Ihumātao "malcontents who got so much unjustified publicity, sticking mainly in the throat of traditional Māori".

He says his party said no to Labour "three times" during the search for a solution to the situation at Ihumātao, and refused a request from its coalition partner to invoke the "agree to disagree" clause.

"For us, it was a matter of deep principle. For us, it was fundamental to whether we maintained confidence in Labour. So we told Labour that. And staved off any action before the election."

Peters says Labour will do a deal over Ihumātao if elected - and that deal would cause a "domino effect".

"If you don't want a new wave of claims on previously settled Treaty [of Waitangi] claims, it's in your hands... If the Crown weakens its resolve after the election you just watch the flood of action on previously settled Treaty claims.

"All of a sudden new 'sacred ground' will be discovered all around the country. And if that happens the whole Treaty framework will unravel and the cost will be unbearable."

Peters says Labour leader Jacinda Ardern "halted the Fletchers housing development at Ihumātao" without consultation New Zealand First, which should have occurred as per their coalition agreement.

"That intervention was a terrible decision. The land's history was that it was freely sold to Fletchers by the local iwi, the keepers of the land."

He criticised Pania Newton, who led action to stop the housing development including an occupation of the land, saying she "sought to overturn a legitimate sale. Worse, she seeks to create an entire new wave of Treaty claims. To perpetuate grievance, to unpick settled Treaty architecture."

Peters says New Zealand First would stop any "dangerous settlement at Ihumātao" if elected.

Ihumātao group calls Peters' comments 'dangerous'

Save Our Unique Landscape (SOUL) is the protest group leading the occupation at Ihumātao and spokesperson Qiane Matata-Sipu says: "What I have read of his speech ... I did see the content of it. First of all, he is lying. A lot of the kōrero in his speech is absolute lies. And if he is campaigning on lies and scaremongering then that's very dangerous.

"He says in his speech that iwi sold the land to Fletchers. Iwi did not sell the land. Iwi did not own the land. The Wallace family sold the land and they acquired that land after it was confiscated. And that's the first lie that I pick up on.

Qiane Matata-Sipu. Photo: RNZ
Qiane Matata-Sipu. Photo: RNZ
"The second one is that he says that Pania Newton is not mana whenua. First of all that is clear defamation. It is absolutely an insult and it is completely rude for someone who has no connection to Ihumātao, who has not been here, who does not know our whānau, our whakapapa, our marae hapu or iwi to claim that someone does not whakapapa or does not have mana whenua there.

"I'm hugely not surprised but disgusted at the fact that he has gone out today and just blatantly lied to scaremonger to win votes."

She said people were still living on the whenua at Ihumātao, and questions about progress towards a resolution would have to be put to the government

Labour says it will keep working towards solution

Labour's finance spokesperson Grant Robertson said: "If we are in a position to form government next term Labour is committed to continuing our work at Ihumātao and finding a solution with all parties involved.

"We have been working hard with all parties involved and believe we can find a solution next term. Labour wants to thank all the parties involved for their work to date. In particular we want to thank Kiingi Tuheitia and his officials for their leadership in this process."

It has been well reported that the coalition government was working on a solution and all parties were aware of that, Robertson said.

Add a Comment




Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter