Concerns over visitors’ impact on wildlife aired

Sophie Barker. Photo: supplied
Sophie Barker. Photo: supplied
The wildlife capital of New Zealand needs to stop visitors "disturbing the wildlife rather than contributing to it", a Dunedin city councillor says.

Cr Sophie Barker — whose mother arrived in Dunedin in 1967 as a freedom camper — said she had a "soft-spot" for the oft-criticised city visitors, but she was concerned Dunedin City Council parks and recreation planner Stephen Hogg’s 2019-20 season-end freedom camping report showed "free wildlife viewing" remained a top drawcard for Dunedin.

A survey by council community rangers shows nearly 70% of freedom campers were visiting Dunedin beaches, nearly 50% used walking tracks, and about 45% were visiting sites for "free wildlife viewing" — the third most popular overall city attraction.

At this week’s full council meeting, Cr Barker called for the council to "focus in the future on a management plan to protect the city’s wildlife".

After the meeting, she said access to wildlife needed to be managed and should not necessarily be free.

Too often visitors were not contributing to the city’s wildlife conservation efforts, were not educated and imagined Dunedin’s wildlife viewing opportunities to be something like a "petting zoo".

"They don’t understand the ‘wild’ in wild animals," Cr Barker said.

"My concern has been those huge, growing numbers of visitors coming to the kind-of-secret beaches and you see what we could perceive as [for example] the impact on yellow-eyed penguin populations.

"I want us to ... make sure that we have a really good destination management plan — and look after the wildlife."

The 2018 Dunedin destination plan — "which had some worthy objectives"— had not lived up to its promise and needed to be redone.

"We need to get moving on this stuff," Cr Barker said.

She asked at the meeting about staff predictions for the coming freedom camping season, given "just 10%" of freedom campers in Dunedin last year were domestic tourists.

Council acting parks and recreation group manager Scott MacLean said staff were "gearing up for a normal season".

Mr Hogg said the Department of Conservation was projecting a "lumpier" visitation curve.

Cr Christine Garey said the estimated $3.7million spend by freedom campers in the city challenged the stereotype some had of the visitors, and vindicated the welcoming attitude the city had for them.

Only Cr Andrew Whiley voiced concerns otherwise.

He said while there were positives around freedom camping, he remained concerned "at times we are giving our city away".

"Freedom camping can work, but it doesn’t always have to be free.

"We are providing a lot of services to these people ... at the expense in most cases to the campgrounds."



Why did Cr Barker not speak up when there were calls to protect the penguin breeding sites from vistors?
The protection and restoration of natural ecosystems should be a top priority for all. It appears that some are more interested in making money from it. Ecotourism is not the only answer! It makes no sense that people cause huge amounts of pollution traveling from all around the world to pay for the privilege to view the wildlife that their lifestyle is killing. The idea that only the privileged well off people will have the right to view our wildlife before it completely disappears is disgusting. I suggest Cr Barker gets out of her ivory tower and starts helping the wildlife by giving back what we have taken from them, their food, their natural environment and the right to live their lives without the interference of people regardless of how wealthy they are.

Tend to agree with Cr Andrew Whiley who 'voiced concerns otherwise'. Freedom Campers may spend an estimated $3.7million in the city, but who to? The food, alcohol, petrol, campervan & tourist companies. Many of them big multinationals, Meanwhile, the residents pay rates and taxes for all the basic facilities that 'freedom campers use'. Water, sewerage, waste disposal, roads, swimming pools, ACC, libraries, art galleries, museums, stadium, and emergency health care. They are not so FREE in other countries.

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter