Man ran over wife twice

A husband who accidentally ran over his wife twice had only months before confessed to being blackmailed over an affair with another woman, an inquest heard today.

Jon Winskill was backing a work ute when he struck Denise Mary Robinson-Winskill, 58, at their Canterbury lifestyle block, instantly killing her.

Just weeks later, he was back on a dating website, the inquest into her death heard today.

Giving evidence at the inquest, Mr Winskill today apologised to the Christchurch schoolteacher's family for his "very irrational and inappropriate'' behaviour.

No criminal charges have been laid by police over the October 23, 2013 incident.

Mr Winskill admitted under cross-examination by Richard Raymond, counsel for Ms Robinson-Winskill's family and three children, that he was prone to flying into fits of frustration or rage when things didn't go his way.

Mr Raymond suggested that was what happened when Mr Winskill, a crop sprayer, had asked his wife of 10 years to turn off a hose he was using to fill up spray tanks on his Toyota Landcruiser work ute - a task she was "hopeless'' at.

"You were frustrated and angry with her. You saw her walk past ... and walk behind the truck, and in your sense of annoyance and frustration, you failed to look out and carelessly reversed,'' Mr Raymond said.

Mr Winskill, who accepted he did not look to see where she was before reversing, denied being frustrated or angry that evening.

He said he has replayed in his mind "a million scenarios'' about what happened that night and he can't figure out what happened.

"I don't accept any scenario because I just don't know what happened.''

Mr Winskill admitted under cross-examination that he had been having an affair with a local Lincoln woman around three months before the accident.

The woman ended up blackmailing him and he paid her $2000 to keep the affair quiet, the inquest heard.

When the woman asked for a further $5000, he confessed the extra-marital relationship to his wife in order to stop the demands.

The "irony'' of the situation was that in the months before her death, their relationship had been "very good", Mr Winskill told the inquest.

Just over a fortnight after his wife's fatal accident, Mr Winskill returned to a dating website, arranging dates with other women, he admitted today.

"That was just my personal way of dealing with shock, loneliness and dealing with what happened,'' he said.

"I am appalled with my behaviour. It was very irrational and inappropriate and I apologise to any family members it has caused distress with.''

He said Mrs Robinson-Winskill knew he regretted the affair and that he had just bought her a new ring and they were planning on a holiday to the islands to renew their vows.

The inquest earlier heard that Mr Winskill was topping up a large water tank on the back of his work ute about 7.45pm for the next day's jobs when he asked his wife to turn off a tap inside a shed, out of his sight.

Mrs Robinson-Winskill eventually found the tap and turned it off, before walking out of the shed.

She walked behind her husband's ute as he was attempting to park in its usual place in a nearby shed.

While he was reversing, he backed over her.

When Mr Winskill realised he'd hit something, he drove forward and ran over her again, Senior Constable Warren Dwyer said.

Mr Winskill ran inside to ring 111 on the landline at 7.53pm, before using a cellphone and rushing back to his wife where he began CPR.

A local Lincoln volunteer fire crew arrived soon after, closely followed by St John ambulance.

Mrs Robinson-Winskill could not be revived and was pronounced dead at the scene.

Police concluded there was no criminal liability or suspicious circumstances surrounding Mrs Robinson-Winskill's death.

Mr Winskill told police at the scene he "just didn't see her''.

"I felt a bump. I got out and there she was,'' Detective Constable Gabrielle Thompson recalled him telling her.

She arrived at the scene just over an hour later and described Mr Winskill as being "distraught'' and "shocked''.

He later told Ms Thompson that when he asked his wife to turn off the tap, he added: "I'm just going to put it back in the shed''.

"She was always so careful. She wouldn't go near farm machinery,'' Mr Winskill said, in explaining why he hadn't checked to see where she was before reversing.

The inquest heard that when Ms Robinson-Winskill's brother Lee Robinson turned up at the Lincoln property that night, Mr Winskill is believed to have said to him, ``F***, what have I done? I don't believe it. What have I done?``

Pathologist Dr Ken Anderson performed a post-mortem the following day.

He found blood and air in her chest cavity around her lungs, along with multiple fractured ribs.

A severe crushing of her upper chest was consistent with being run over by a heavy vehicle, Dr Anderson concluded.

The impact occurred at "very low velocity", the now retired pathologist said, accounting for the lack of impact injuries on her body.

He also found that she had a pre-existing heart valve abnormality, which he mentioned because it can cause fainting attacks and could have been a

"possible relevance'' to the accident.

However, there had been no documented fainting attack in her lifetime.

And Dr Anderson said there had been no facial injuries, which might have been found if she'd fallen to the ground unconscious before being run over.

The inquest, before Coroner David Crerar, continues tomorrow.

 

By Kurt Bayer of NZME News Service


Add a Comment

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter