Banks' guilty verdict will raise spectres to haunt him

John Banks can never escape his past, John Armstrong says.

John Banks will take his guilty verdict for electoral fraud hard - very hard.

His life has come full circle in a manner which he could never have predicted and which will torment him for long after the public tumult surrounding the case has subsided.

The all-powerful driving force in Mr Banks' life, which saw him carve out a successful career as an entrepreneur and led to his natural progression into politics, has been the sheer awfulness of his parents' sordid life of crime.

More precisely, it is his memory of the horror and ignominy of seeing his parents sentenced to prison after being convicted on back-street abortion charges.

Speaking after being forced to stand down as a minister last year - and coming close to breaking down in the process - Mr Banks said he had devoted much of his life to trying ''to balance the family ledger''.

To have ended up in court and on the receiving end of a guilty verdict will have convinced him he has failed in life and failed miserably.

Joining that not-so-exclusive club of MPs who have been thrown out of Parliament for good - an institution which he has graced and loved for more than two decades - will be equally if not more devastating.

In time, however, he will regard the verdict as just another low point in a public life which has been punctuated constantly with noteworthy highs and similarly littered with hard-to-take lows.

But not now. Mr Banks is cursed with being a perfectionist. But the world of politics is imperfect. It has a habit of throwing a curve ball out of nowhere.

And Mr Banks - who would have thought he was off the hook after the police opted not to press charges - got one which he will argue to his dying day he never deserved.

But as much as he has been found guilty of rorting the handling of political donations, he is more guilty of foolishness.

For that reason, it would be silly to send him to prison. That, anyway, looks unlikely to happen.

During a career in politics at both the national and local level, he could play the game as roughly as anyone.

He once used one of his radio programmes to describe a Herald political reporter, who had penned a few negative but pretty innocuous remarks rebuking Mr Banks for something he had done as a minister, as ''a streak of weasel's piss''.

But behind the bravado lies a very human heart.

He has a genuine and lasting regard for those with whom he has crossed paths. He is capable of extraordinary acts of kindness.

Apart from the events which saw him end up in court, his biggest mistake was to return to national politics three years ago as Act's sole MP. He has not had a happy time.

Parliamentary life had changed a lot during his 12-year absence. Being a lone MP has made things even tougher.

Who could forget the night in the House when Labour picked at him like buzzards feeding on roadkill? That is not a criticism of Labour. Mr Banks simply had no colleagues to protect him.

Yet, equally, anyone listening to the House in January will not forget his speech on income inequality. This was no academic treatise - and all the more powerful for not being so.

As someone who had experienced grinding poverty - unlike the great majority of MPs - he made a plea for an end to government borrowing to fund ever more welfare.

''I know what it is like going to school every day in an ex-army uniform with no shoes; spending all day, every day, out of the classroom stealing other kids' lunches; going home to bread and milk - at best - at night, cooked over an open fire with sugar on top; if I am very lucky, taking Weet-Bix covered in dripping to school each day; and living in a very dark hole. That is child poverty.''

The speech moved other MPs in the House regardless of political allegiance.

But it was also a reminder that as much as he might try, he can never escape his past.

John Armstrong is The New Zealand Herald political correspondent.


Add a Comment

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter