Queenstown Bunnings accused of wanting cultural performers on the cheap

Bunnings Building in South Dunedin. Photo by Peter McIntosh.
Bunnings is under fire from Mana Tāhuna. Photo: ODT files
A Māori charitable trust in Queenstown is accusing Bunnings Warehouse of wanting cultural performers on the cheap.

Mana Tāhuna said it was asked to do a dawn karakia and waiata to open a new store but the company went looking elsewhere when it was told the fee would be $500.

The trust is furious but Bunnings insists there's been a misunderstanding.

Mana Tāhuna is a charitable trust on a mission to improve the lives of Māori in Queenstown and help develop a strong presence in the community.

It aims to create jobs and training for locals as well as providing advice to businesses about when and how to include Māori culture or tikanga.

Chair Darren Rewi said the local Bunnings Warehouse earlier this year emailed the trust asking it to perform karakia and waiata at the store opening which took place early April.

He told the company there would be a fee.

"It was a nominal figure, we just put $500 as a koha for what we were trying to achieve and engage with them. We got no reply, they just disengaged and then they started ringing up whānau and any Māori in town to try and perform those cultural services."

Rewi is furious about what's happened.

After he raised concerns with Bunnings they offered a donation but by that stage it was too late and the company had already approached other people, Rewi said.

"They were doing the dial a Māori, trying to get anyone or someone to do it that had brown skin, that was really offensive and it's an unsafe space for whānau to enter because Bunnings don't seem to want to engage with us," he claims.

Bunnings has denied going to other Māori to do the blessing.

Company spokesperson Jacqui Coombes said in a statement there was a breakdown in communication and the company had no problem paying for tikanga services.

"When he [Darren] decided not to participate we also offered him the donation as a goodwill gesture, which he chose to decline.

"Following the store opening, I met with Darren Rewi to hear his perspective, and attempt to clear up any confusion so we can improve in the future."

Neither Rewi nor Bunnings would say how much was offered.

Human rights, diversity and anti-racism writer and researcher Dr Rawiri Taonui said the trust's alleged experience was all too common for Māori when it came to providing cultural tikanga.

"It's about pākeha recognising that tikanga is work and that it takes time, effort and expertise to perform those roles."

Taonui said non-Māori wanting tikanga services needed to contact Mana Whenua or the local iwi first and be prepared to pay for the valuable guidance and expertise they are getting.

"It mainly comes down to the assumptions that Pākeha make, on one hand they want to do something that's cross-cultural and good, but they fail to recognise the time, effort and expertise that lies behind those roles.

"The approach that needs to be taken is early consultation, full and frank consultation, preferably face to face and then you won't have these sorts of mis-understandings occurring," said Taonui.

Bunnings would not be interviewed saying they were now in mediation with the trust.

Rewi said he would like an acknowledgement of the mamae caused and for future communication to be clearer and face to face.

Comments

As I high school student in a jazz band, I performed at a teacher's wedding for 10 bucks.
And we did our thing for an hour.
500 for a couple of people to perform a 5 minute cultural thing is pretty good money.
Considering displaying my culture for so little, maybe they should ask a more reasonable rate

Sooooo ... Is there a law stating you must have karakia or waiata for opening a shop ? .... (why you even would in the first place is also a relevant question it's just a shop...) but anyway Bunnings try to do the right thing ... Don't like the price and move on.

Fair enough isn't it?

They're there to make money after all. This is a massive over reaction and hardly newsworthy.

This matter should have been dealt with between Bunnings and Mana Tahuna privately. Once you involve Human rights, diversity and anti-racism writer and researcher Dr Rawiri Taonui and then spread the story across the media, the damage is done. What often results is a paranoia from Pakeha to never engage with Maori in the future. The whole thing is simply put into the too hard basket. As well intentioned as the desire for cultural tikanga may have initially been, it certainly isn’t worth the ever-lurking (in this case subtle) accusation of racism, descending over what was essentially just general bad communication and a possible lack of direct honesty.
Don’t become embroiled, the conversation should have been as follows:
Bunnings: “I thank you for your time, but sadly $500 is more than we would like to spend on that part of our opening ceremony.”
Mana Tahuna: “No problem, well that’s our price if you change your mind. I wish you well for your opening, Goodbye.”

There shouldn't even be a fee. Charging money for karakia is repulsive. If it really is a koha (voluntary donation) it wouldn't have a price tag on it, therefore call it what it is, a fee.

 

drivesouth-pow-generic-1.png

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter