Closure of H&Js, new supermarket coming

It was a day of mixed feelings in Balclutha yesterday, as employment fortunes ebbed and flowed.

As the town reeled under the news nine jobs would be lost at the long-standing, town centre H&J Smith department store, Countdown restated its commitment to building a new supermarket in Balclutha, bringing with it up to 80 positions.

Clutha Mayor Bryan Cadogan said the news was ‘‘symptomatic’’ of the situation following Covid-19’s dramatic effects on the economy.

‘‘You never know quite what’s coming at you.

Bittersweet ... Clutha Mayor Bryan Cadogan stands in front of the proposed site of a new...
Bittersweet ... Clutha Mayor Bryan Cadogan stands in front of the proposed site of a new Countdown supermarket on Balclutha's Clyde St yesterday, after the announcement of the planned closure of the town's H&J Smith department store.PHOTO: RICHARD DAVISON

‘‘Our thoughts are with the staff and their families right now, but there’s also a positivity to be taken that we’re still in a position where ... we can look to the future.’’

He said Countdown had informed him the Covid-19 crisis had not significantly affected its plans for a 2500sq m supermarket opposite the town’s War Memorial Hall.

Countdown head of property Matt Grainger confirmed this was the case, saying Covid-19 delays meant work would start ‘‘late this year’’.

‘‘We’re really pleased to have received consent to build a brand new store in Balclutha. It’s a part of the country we’ve been looking at for some time, and we think a Countdown will provide a great new choice for the community.’’

The store was expected to create about 80 jobs, and would open during the second half of next year, he said.

Mr Cadogan described the situation as ‘‘one step forward, one step back’’, and said economic development agency Clutha Development would be working to link people with jobs through its new ‘‘Work Local’’ initiative, launched this week.

He urged residents to consider shopping local to prevent further business closures.

‘‘It’s time to circle the wagons, [and] see that there’s a bigger picture than convenience. Go down and tell H&Js how convenient online shopping is.’’



Don't get sucked in by the Countdown spin. The population isn't going to double when they open their supermarket, therefore the existing population doing their supermarket shopping is going to split between the existing supermarkets and Countdown. So the existing supermarkets turnover will also drop and so will their staff requirements. However, any NEW jobs will help the Balclutha economy.

Local journalism matters - now more than ever

As the Covid-19 pandemic brings the world into uncharted waters, Otago Daily Times reporters and photographers continue to bring you the stories that matter. For more than 158 years our journalists have provided readers with local news you can trust. This is more important now than ever.

As advertising drops off during the pandemic, support from our readers is crucial. You can help us continue to bring you news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter