Cockleshell design on ice; still part of plan

Architecture Van Brandenburg’s cockleshell-shaped building proposed for the Steamer Basin area....
Architecture Van Brandenburg’s cockleshell-shaped building proposed for the Steamer Basin area. PHOTO: ANIMATION RESEARCH
Plans to build a cockleshell-shaped building at the heart of Dunedin's waterfront development plan appear to be on ice, at least for now, but the concept is not dead, the Dunedin City Council says.

It was confirmed yesterday the city's bid for $100 million from the Provincial Growth Fund to support the waterfront project had included about $50 million to build the first of three cockleshell-shaped structures.

That would have set the tone for the wider development, in keeping with the concept plan given to the city by Damien van Brandenburg, of Architecture Van Brandenburg, it was suggested at the time.

However, after PGF officials baulked at the size of the sum being sought, the council agreed to submit a revised bid for $44million, council chief executive Sue Bidrose confirmed this week.

The money was to cover the cost of upgrading sea walls and wharves, and establishing building platforms, in the Steamer Basin area.

That led to this week's announcement $19.9 million from the fund would be allocated to support the first stage of work, focused on the north side of Steamer Basin.

Dr Bidrose said the PGF was ultimately not considered to be "the appropriate place" to seek funding for the cockleshell structures, as it did not offer the same potential to drive economic development.

The cockleshell complex has previously been earmarked as a cultural centre on the waterfront, possibly providing a new home for part of Te Papa's national collection or Ralph Hotere's work.

Dr Bidrose said the decision to drop the cost of the cockleshell work from the bid, and to split the rest of the work into at least two stages, did not mean the concept was dead.

There were no immediate plans to seek alternative sources of funding for the cockleshells, but they remained part of the "grand vision" for the waterfront, she said.

"That's down the track ... that's phase three," she said.

It was also possible work on the structures could come sooner than that, if plans for a five-star hotel in the area attracted a developer who also wanted a convention centre nearby, she indicated.

"Then suddenly it becomes something that we might look for partners to develop.

"It's not out of the picture. It's still pretty linchpin for the development, but right now our focus is going to be on starting phase one and the consenting for the whole thing," she said.

Mr van Brandenburg, contacted overseas, said the financial contribution from the PGF was still "really positive" for the project.

"It is a vote of confidence from central government and adds momentum to the waterfront vision."

Dunedin businessman Ian Taylor, who has joined Mr van Brandenburg in promoting the concept, said the cockleshell structures would "always be the hardest" to deliver.

He understood, and accepted, the reasons why the government could not give the waterfront project $100 million, but remained confident the cockleshells would "always" be part of the project.

"Where we need to turn our focus now is to take what we've been offered and keep building the case for the city to grow ... that's what gives private developers the confidence [to invest]," he said.


Ha ha ha nobody except the half a dozen clowns that want this will be losing any sleep about those hideous things not being there,here's an idea how about spending that money on roads and infrastructure instead of a vanity project like this.

So the Council were fully aware that the $100 million request had previously been declined so resubmitted for $44m, of which Dunedin received only $19m. All of this information withheld whilst this group of Councillors lobbied for re-election. Dunedin have successfully voted for more of the same - good work Dunedin, you can remain in your time warp!

The concept drawing and models for this part of town should only be considered as that - just a concept. Take a run down neglected piece of foreshore and turn it into a vibrant living area. And that includes the dream time $20 million bridge.

I note no one has said what these buildings would be used for. Dunedin certainly doesn't need another museum. Maybe a bay side retreat for retired councilors and their egos?

The land should be offered in a public open competition. Let designers and developers show what they can do without using buckets of public money.

It has taken years for DCC to offer the Moray St car park in a tender. You would hope they learnt some lessons from that debacle.

The DCC is unable to get the hospital built, they aren't going to be able to get this monstrosity built either. The only thing DCC can build and regulate is parking. DCC views parking lots as a source of income. Look at the airport; we have a huge parking lot but limited flight options. Between parking and bike lanes nothing will ever come to fruition on the project.

What has the hospital build got to do with the DCC? Central government is building it.
Taking anti progress comments to a whole new level.



Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter