Mayor blames ‘external factors’ for loss of 5 councillors

Clutha Mayor Bryan Cadogan. Photo: Stephen Jaquiery
Clutha Mayor Bryan Cadogan. Photo: Stephen Jaquiery

 

Mel Foster
Mel Foster

A southern mayor is blaming "external factors" for the loss of five incumbent councillors at the coming local elections.

Clutha Mayor Bryan Cadogan said he was concerned to be losing a third of his current council — including his deputy mayor — as nominations for this October’s local government elections open on Friday.

The Otago Daily Times contacted all 14 Clutha councillors on Monday to confirm electoral plans.

Incumbents Mel Foster (Lawrence-Tuapeka ward), John Herbert and Lloyd McCall (both West Otago), Carol Sutherland (Balclutha) and deputy mayor Stewart Cowie (Clutha Valley) all confirmed they would stand down this October.

Lloyd McCall
Lloyd McCall
Mr Cadogan said he was sorry to be losing "five good councillors", and in part blamed the current "challenging" political environment.

"This is a wealth of experience, knowledge and community connection we’re losing at this election, especially during a period of considerable external flux.

"You might expect to change a couple of councillors at any given election, but to lose five is a concern."

Mr Cadogan’s reasoning was borne out by some departees.

Cr Herbert (53) — a veteran of three consecutive community board and two council terms — said "polite and inoffensive" public debate over political differences appeared to be a thing of the past.

John Herbert
John Herbert
"It can be difficult on your family at times. We don’t go out socially locally, as it’s just not worth it."

The Heriot farmer said he planned to step away from public life more widely to concentrate on diversifying his business interests.

Deputy mayor Cowie (67) said his departure after four terms should not be taken as a slight to Mr Cadogan.

"It’s never been my wish or intention to challenge Bryan as mayor. I’ve always supported him, and continue to do so."

The Te Houka farmer said political differences were simply a factor of standing for office.

Stewart Cowie
Stewart Cowie
"You can’t worry too much about the bellyachers."

Cr McCall (63), who joined the council during a by-election in March last year, said he was stepping down to "follow his environmental passions" and stand for Otago Regional Council once again.

The Tapanui agricultural and environmental consultant was an unsuccessful candidate for the Molyneux ward in 2019.

Cr Foster (54) will stand down after just one term, and depart Lawrence for Dunedin or Christchurch.

She said she had enjoyed the challenge of local government, and would not rule out standing for office again in her new community.

Carol Sutherland
Carol Sutherland

Cr Sutherland (75) said "age" was the key factor for her decision to step down after two terms.

"It’s not always been smooth sailing with matters like 3 Waters, but I’ve enjoyed working with some excellent people in council. It’s time for some younger candidates to step up."

Mr Cadogan thanked the departing councillors for their service to the district.

richard.davison@odt.co.nz