Brisbane great Lockyer was a frontrunner in 2017 to be inducted when Rugby League Week (RLW) magazine was on the cusp of naming a ninth Immortal, only for the publication to be closed and all its intellectual property, including the Immortals concept, bought by the NRL.
The NRL’s judging panel went back to the distant past by honouring Dally Messenger, Frank Burge and Dave Brown. Norm Provan and Mal Meninga made up the five new Immortals inducted in 2018.
It was a break from the RLW pattern of mostly moving forward with each of the previous Immortals. The initial four of John Raper, Reg Gasnier, Bob Fulton and Clive Churchill were inducted in 1981. Then followed Graeme Langlands and Wally Lewis in 1999, Arthur Beetson in 2003 and Andrew Johns in 2012.
The late and great Ian Heads, former editor of RLW, addressed the Immortals judging panel in 2012 and told them of the philosophy of the initial 1981 judges Harry Bath, Frank Hyde and Tom Goodman.
"They came up with two fundamental guidelines which underpin the Immortals concept to this day: firstly, that their preference collectively was to choose only from footballers they had seen play," Heads said.
"So the line was drawn and the decision made that the Immortals would be chosen from Australia’s post-war players."
That ethos continued until 2018, when the judges decided that if they did not honour the founding fathers it would never happen.
In 2012, there was a strong view that Lockyer should be an Immortal, but the rule at the time was that a player had to be retired for at least five years. That is now three.
"If we had inducted an Immortal in 2017 then ‘Locky’ would have been an absolute certainty, because we would have had the same judging panel and probably added to it," former RLW editor Martin Lenehan said in 2018.
"The same people in 2012 who thought he should be an Immortal would have been involved again," he said.
In 2016 Lockyer was interviewed by a RLW journalist about the Immortals concept and who should be next.
The story never saw the light of day because of the magazine’s termination, but AAP can reveal what Lockyer said.
"From my perspective, when I think of the guys that are already in there as Immortals the fact that I am even mentioned in the conversation is humbling," Lockyer said.
"I don’t put myself in that category."
He said his former Broncos captain Allan Langer should be in the frame.
"I played a lot of footy with Alf and he just won so many games for us with the Broncos and for Queensland at Origin level," Lockyer said.
Langer, Parramatta duo Brett Kenny and Peter Sterling, along with Brad Fittler are all understood to be on the short list on Wednesday night, along with Lockyer and Smith.
