Stop the Stadium to pay court costs

Jim Harland
Jim Harland
Stop the Stadium has been ordered to pay almost $10,000 court costs following its unsuccessful High Court bid in April to scuttle Dunedin's stadium project.

High Court judge Justice Lester Chisholm has released his decision on the matter, ruling the Dunedin City Council should receive $9740, and council chief executive Jim Harland made it clear yesterday the council expected payment.

"We will recover the debt that is owing to us."

Mr Harland said there "may or may not" be liability issues for senior members of the organisation.

Stop the Stadium president Dave Witherow blasted the decision as "another confirmation that the people of Dunedin have been deprived of every aspect of a functioning democracy".

"The dereliction of the courts is especially worrying, given their acknowledgement that the Dunedin City Council, in its evidence, had misled the High Court."

He said the only way to "restore democracy and fair-dealing" was at election time.

"The local body elections are a year away. They have never been more important."

Asked about the group's future, he said that would be discussed at a committee meeting and general meeting "probably within the next couple of months".

Asked if it could or would pay the money, he said that was a decision for members.

Stop the Stadium secretary Carol Sawyer said all legal bills had been paid, and court costs were the only amount the organisation owed.

There had been no decision yet for costs from the appeal hearing, but they were not expected to be more than $5000.

The group had lodged a $4740 bond, so no further expense was expected.

The council applied for $11,203 costs, while Stop the Stadium applied for $17,513.

In his decision, Justice Chisholm said the application for costs was opposed by Stop the Stadium on the basis the case was "a public interest proceeding of great significance to the Dunedin community".

Counsel Len Andersen had argued an award of costs would "do nothing to heal the wounds created by the stadium dispute, and that although the court concluded that the plaintiff could not prove its case, this was not a situation where the court was satisfied that the plaintiff was wrong".

But Justice Chisholm said the party that failed should pay costs to the party that succeeded.

Stop the Stadium was registered as an incorporated society in July last year.

Asked about the legal situation, council counsel Frazer Barton said, like any company, it could vote to dissolve.

"There can be legal issues at times if liabilities were incurred when a company did not have sufficient assets.

"In certain circumstances, directors can be personally liable."

He did not think it was likely former president Bev Butler could be held responsible if the debt was not paid.

"Obviously, everything will have to be looked at. I would not rate that [possibility] particularly highly."

In April, Ms Butler said there was no plan to dissolve Stop The Stadium in order to avoid paying for the council's costs.

Yesterday she said as she was no longer president or spokeswoman, she was unable to comment.

- david.loughrey@odt.co.nz

 

Add a Comment

 

Advertisement

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter