Govt website contradicts PM's KFC worker claim

Jacinda Ardern. Photo: Getty
Jacinda Ardern. Photo: Getty
A government-run group that informs New Zealanders about the latest Covid-19 information is contradicting the Prime Minister's stance surrounding a KFC worker who she says should have been isolating.

The Unite Against Covid-19 Facebook, Twitter and Instagram pages have been hugely popular with the public - often replying to questions about all things Covid in great detail and in real-time.

But one member of the public's comment calling out "people like the selfish Kmart worker" resulted in the Unite Against Covid-19 page seemingly correcting her.

"Kia J (Kmart worker) and Case L (KFC worker) were not required to isolate at the time," the page says.

"The advice for all staff and students of Papatoetoe High School to isolate was updated on 23 February - after the two had attended their shifts at their workplaces."

The page says that close contacts and their families were advised to isolate and to get a Covid test.

The message posted on the Unite Against Covid-19 Facebook page. Image: Facebook
The message posted on the Unite Against Covid-19 Facebook page. Image: Facebook
Casual plus contacts were also told to get a test and self-isolate. However, their household members were not required to.

"The family complied with the advice they were given at the time," the page writes.

The comment was posted four days ago - around the same time the PM voiced her frustrations over the family member of a Papatoetoe High student, who tested positive for Covid-19, who went to work at KFC Botany Downs.

The worker later tested positive for the virus.

Asked at the time whether the person should have been at home isolating, Ardern said: "Yes, they should have.

"They were always told they weren't meant to be operating in a level 2 environment.

"They were still required to stay at home and be tested."

'Someone owes someone an apology'

The KFC worker - dubbed Case L - is from the same household as the teenager, known as Case J, who went to work at Kmart Botany while infectious.

In the past few days, the KFC staffer says she was never told she needed to self-isolate at home and that Ardern needed to apologise to her.

"It's not fair on our end that we're getting all this backlash for something that we haven't actually done," she told Discovery.

Ardern yesterday said she would not be apologising and revealed that 15 texts and phone calls were made to that particular family.

"In my mind, everyone at Papatoetoe High School getting a test felt really clear to me," Ardern said.

National Party leader Judith Collins is also backing the KFC worker - saying "someone owes someone an apology".

She said if the Facebook post is right, then Ardern needs to front up and apologise to the affected employee.

"It now appears the Health Ministry - via a Facebook post - has confirmed the KFC worker who was vilified for going to work instead of staying home was told not to self-isolate by health officials."

She said the communications coming from the Government had left a lot to be desired, of late.

"The invention of new terms on the fly like 'casual plus' and 'close plus' contacts is confusing too many people," Collins said.

"The Government needs to get its public messaging right. Communication breakdowns like this can be the difference between Kiwis living Covid-free and a lockdown that costs the New Zealand economy $500 million a week."


Someone is telling lies, pity the govt isn't more transparent and releases the records.

This whole story is a nonsense, its not even a storm in a teacup. In the overall scheme of the pandemic it is meaningless.
To a certain extent it is amusing to watch crusher and Seymour and for that matter nivaman posturing and spluttering over such mediocrity. If this is all the heat the opposition can muster then NZ politics are in a real sorry state.
Bring back Simon, his irrelevancies are far more entertaining.

c'mon man, you are missing the point, we know you are trying to defend your party, it's just a pity they aren't as transparent as they purport to be.

Oh come on.
If this was happening under a National govt you'd be screaming from the rooftops.

As I've regularly stated in this fine publication, when the National Party dimwits troll me, I do not have a party - I'm politically neutral. I call the shots as I see them. In this case, the Opposition are clearly, desperately, trying to find something - anything - to try and damage the Govt. They are constantly picking the wrong issue. Last week it was Simon Bridges with his police gang statistics nonsense and completely missing the real story over a sick police culture; this week it's Crusher and Seymour on an irrelevant, he said, she said Covid 19 story. The reality is that our Govt has managed one of the best pandemic strategies in the world, by any measure. That's not my biased opinion, it's the opinion of the world at large.

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter