Political tactics are race-blind - Hone's surely a goner

Ignore the flowery twaddle being talked up in Maoridom about how the prosecution of Hone Harawira ought to have proceeded according to the principles of kaupapa Maori from the very start.

When push comes to shove - and Mr Harawira must surely get the final shove from the Maori Party next week - the punishment being meted out to the renegade MP demonstrates that day-to-day political tactics are essentially race-blind; that there is no Maori world-view to fall back on here that would see things done any differently.

Realpolitik rules, OK?

Perhaps more so in this instance. Pita Sharples' warning that the collapse of the Maori Party could result in a future without any kind of Maori party was a very sobering thought, which Maori leaders have taken on board.

No wonder Tariana Turia - effectively Mr Harawira's judge and jury - showed not a skerrick of mercy in ejecting him from the party's caucus. She wants him out of the party. And what Mrs Turia wants, Mrs Turia gets.

If the party's disciplinary committee fails to make the required recommendation to the party's national council then Mrs Turia's authority - along with Dr Sharples' - will be in tatters. That is unthinkable. There can be only one outcome.

Mr Harawira's exit has been a case of deja vu for National and Labour. When it comes to dealing with rebels, they have been there, done that - and many times over.

The immediate thing bothering John Key and Phil Goff was how much the media focus on Mr Harawira would shift attention away from the Prime Minister's annual statement to Parliament, delivered on the first sitting day of the year.

Mr Harawira's fate is of only passing interest for the two major parties this side of the election.

Afterwards, it will be a different story if he holds his seat, however. Such distractions will punctuate election year.

But the run-up to this election will be dominated by economic growth or, more particularly, the lack of it.

The economy will be the crucial determinant in whether National can get the 45% of the vote it will almost certainly need to get as a minimum to stay in government. A big ask.

Moreover, it will take only a slippage of a few percentage points for National to miss out and for victory to be Labour's and the Greens'. A continuing or further slump in economic activity which triggered even a small exodus of voters could be devastating for National.

One question Mr Harawira's demise does pose for Mr Key is the degree to which the former's forthright attacks on National have resonated with the Maori Party's wider membership. Only Labour stands to benefit from the ructions, either by picking up more Maori votes or the Maori Party switching allegiance post-election.

That is one reason why Labour is pitching a message to low-income earners citing the pressure on families from the rising cost of living, while trying to compound voter unhappiness by arguing National's last round of tax cuts mainly benefited the already well off.

National this week sought to combat that line of attack with figures showing that the average after-tax wage had risen 16% since 2008, whereas consumer prices had risen only 6%. The figures take in three rounds of tax cuts, including Labour's last- minute ones which took effect from October 2008, shortly before National swept to power in that year's election.

National has not tried to hide Labour's contribution to its argument. But neither has it publicised it. It simply argues that compilation of the measure would be too difficult if Labour's cuts were not included.

Labour counters by arguing that no other country uses after-tax figures and that the better measure is income growth before tax. Labour says National has failed miserably, with average incomes rising only 0.4%. Moreover, the international recession is no excuse given Australian incomes have risen further.

Labour could strike a chord here. People do measure the progress they are making by increases in their gross wage or salary.

Mr Goff also intends to attack Mr Key over his rhetoric not matching reality. At the start of each year, the Prime Minister has praised New Zealanders for coming through tough times, while holding out the prospect of better times ahead.

That has not happened. Labour argues this is because National lacks an economic plan.

Labour asserts that selling a minority stake in some state-owned enterprises while dismantling the public service does not add up to one.

Mr Key and Finance Minister Bill English remain pretty relaxed, however, about Labour's attempt to fight the election on an issue with which they feel they have a clear advantage in terms of credibility and majority voter backing for the overall policy direction.

The Government was rocked, however, just before the Christmas break by Statistics New Zealand figures showing the economy contracting 0.2% in the September quarter of last year.

Since then, anecdotal evidence picked up by Government ministers suggests economic confidence is growing again, albeit slowly.

No-one, however, is in the business of making predictions. Good news keeps being swallowed up by bad. High export commodity prices are being offset by fears of a slowdown in the Australian economy - New Zealand's biggest export market.

The uncertain outlook is making even an optimist like Mr Key hedge his language, while Mr English conceded this week that New Zealand could experience a double-dip recession.

While the fiscal stimulus provided by tax cuts and increased government spending saw the economy weather the international downturn, domestic consumption has nose-dived as householders and farmers use spare cash to cut personal debt.

Likewise, the Government is now preaching austerity. This year's Budget will be National's tightest - an unusual phenomenon in an election year.

National, however, firmly believes that the Government's penchant for restraint is very much in line with the public's mood for such. Mr English's job is to keep that symmetry intact.

For at some point, the public's low expectations will change to rising ones.

And throughout history, the track record shows that revolutions occur and administrations fall when governments cannot meet rising expectations, rather than static ones.


Add a Comment

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter