'Devastated': Anger as deal to move toxic chemicals falls over

The flooded Mataura River rips past the former Mataura paper mill. Photo: Stephen Jaquiery
The flooded Mataura River rips past the former Mataura paper mill. Photo: Stephen Jaquiery
The potentially dangerous chemical being stored in the former Mataura paper mill will not be moved any time soon after a deal to move the dross was turned down.

Almost 10,000 tonnes of ouvea premix, a by-product of the smelting process, was dumped at the site in 2014 by Taha, which was under contract to New Zealand Aluminium Smelter to provide a zero waste solution for the substance.

A "handshake deal" was made with concerned parties last week, but Gore District Council (GDC)  mayor Tracy Hicks said today the Rio Tinto board turned it down.

"It's fair to say everybody is feeling pretty sick.

"I'm annoyed at how this has played out and the performance of Rio Tinto over this period."

When wet, the substance is capable of generating ammonia gas, which could be harmful to human health or the environment.

Floods in the region this week sparked fears the chemicals could become saturated and hazardous.

Mr Hicks questioned whether some of the millions the company would be saving in its "sweetheart deal” over power, could be used to expedite the removal of the dross.

Gore District Chief Executive Stephen Parry today announced the deal he had struck with New Zealand Aluminium Smelters CEO Stewart Hamilton has been scuppered by Rio Tinto.

"To say I am devastated is an understatement.

"We had a deal, sealed with a good old-fashioned Southland handshake, but Rio Tinto’s bosses have reneged.”

He said the deal would have resulted in the dross being removed from Mataura by the end of June and sent to a building on the Tiwai Point complex for storage. The building is not part of Analco's processing plant at Tiwai.

"It’s my understanding from conversations with Stewart that Rio Tinto’s rationale for refusing to take the dross was that it didn’t want any more liabilities on the Tiwai site before the company’s strategic review is completed at the end of March.”

Mr Parry said the original deal struck with all Southland councils, landowners and NZAS to move the dross stored throughout Southland was still in place.

"However, at this point I can’t offer Mataura residents any concrete method by which we can accelerate the removal process.

"It would be ideal if Stewart Hamilton could attend the meeting in Mataura, on Friday, to explain to our residents in more detail why his company can’t take the dross.”

Mr Hamilton issued a statement to the Otago Daily Times saying: "We have fully co-operated with GDC regarding the council’s long-standing plans to remove the material that is stored at the Mataura Paper Mill. 

"We remain committed to a solution that removes the material.  NZAS has committed to contributing $1.75 million to the costs of safely removing and processing the material."

Mr Hicks condemned NZAS’s performance in managing its contract with Taha.

A press release from Gore District Council said when the council became aware it was at the mill, it was advised to allow Taha to apply for a resource consent retrospectively.

A consent was issued with a number of conditions, including a $2.3million bond. Taha appealed the bond and did not pay anything to the Council.

Taha went into liquidation and its principals left NZ for Bahrain during mediation in the Environment Court with the Council.

The catalyst for Taha going into liquidation was NZAS not renewing its contract with the company. 


This is ridiculous. The Rio Tinto board are sitting around laughing at the small town country bumpkins (Mayors, Power companies, Central Government) who let them do whatever they want at Tiwai.

Even if it is moved, where is it moved too? Was Taha's contract really for a "zero waste" solution, or was it just a "pay to pass the buck" scenario, where the shell company is folded and the big multi-national PR team can say it has nothing to do with us.

It's time we hardened up and called their bluff. Pay full price for power, genuinely have a robust, transparent, fully owned process for zero waste, and welcome randomly timed auditors in to check.

If this doesn't work for Rio Tinto, they can take their poison and exploitation elsewhere. We cannot bow to these soul-less, profit centric, corporates in return for a few wage packets!






Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter