Businessman slams leasehold 'parasite'

Alistair Broad.
Alistair Broad.
Leasehold land is a ''parasite'' killing development in Dunedin, property owner and businessmen Alistair Broad says.

Mr Broad, of Dunedin, says property developers are reluctant to invest in Dunedin because of the large amount of leasehold land.

The Otago Regional Council - the 100% owner of Port Otago, which operates the subsidiary Chalmers Properties - owns a ''startling'' amount of leasehold land in Dunedin.

It needed to be made freehold to encourage development, he says.

The land was a major revenue gathering force but was a ''clog on Dunedin's development''.

''It's a careless parasite that kills its host.''

Mr Broad, the husband of Dunedin city councillor Hilary Calvert, said

the amount of leasehold land in the city meant freehold farmland on the Taieri and land north of Milton was being converted into industrial land instead.

Grant Paterson, of Dunedin - the former half-owner of a dairy processing plant built in 2011 - said it could have been built in Dunedin, but it was easier to build in South Otago.

A reason against building in Dunedin was the lack of available freehold industrial land in the city, he said.

Building on leasehold land was undesirable and a search for suitable freehold land in Dunedin was unsuccessful, he said.

''There's no land available - it's all leasehold. We looked around, couldn't find anything and it was far better doing it in South Otago.''

With the plant going elsewhere, Dunedin missed out on 70 ''high-paying'' jobs and plenty of ''downstream'' work, such as trucking.

Mr Paterson said he ''didn't bother'' approaching Chalmers Properties about making some of its leasehold land portfolio freehold to build the plant.

''They are not going to do that - they've got a big property portfolio.''

The plant - recently bought by French dairy company Danone - was expected to finish about 18,000 tonnes of dairy nutritional products this year, he said.

Otago Chamber of Commerce chief executive John Christie said many business people believed less leasehold land in Dunedin would spur more development in the city.

''Leasehold is definitely less desirable, no matter who owns it.''

Equity in buildings on leasehold land had been lost when land values increased, Mr Christie said.

Leasehold land limited options for investors seeking purpose-built industrial sites in Dunedin.

However, ''pockets'' of industrial land were available in Dunedin, including Kaikorai Valley Rd and Carisbrook. Chalmers Properties had indicated to the board it would freehold land to a suitable development, he said.

''There are options there, but I do know there is a certain undercurrent of people who are pretty disgruntled about leasehold land in this city.''

Dunedin City Council chief executive Sue Bidrose said leasehold land presented challenges to building owners and for that reason the council gave its leasehold building owners the chance to buy the land from the council.

''The council had systematically divested itself of all of our leasehold land that was on commercial premises.''

The council owned an area of leasehold land which had a building tenanted by a non-commercial community organisation, she said.

The Otago Foundation Trust Board is also a major owner of leasehold land - mostly commercial - in Dunedin.

The trust administers funds for the Synod of Otago and Southland - the regional court of the Presbyterian Church of Aotearoa New Zealand.

The trust declined to go into detail about how much land it owned but believed it was not the biggest owner of leasehold land in Dunedin.

Add a Comment



Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter